Musae in Concert

TIDINGS OF COMFORT AND JOY

Saturday December 7, 2024

Noe Valley Ministry
1021 Sanchez Street, San Francisco

Sunday December 8, 2024

Old St. Hilary's Landmark
201 Esperanza Street, Tiburon

Dear Friends and Supporters,

Welcome to Musae’s Winter Concerts, Tidings of Comfort and Joy. We’re so glad you’re here with us to share in the magic of music, connection, comfort, and celebration.

As we enter this holiday season, many of us are navigating complex emotions and experiences. It can be hard to feel the warmth of the holidays when so much weighs on our hearts and minds. With this in mind, I wanted to curate a program that could offer resilience and solace, and to help us reconnect with joy, even when it feels distant. My hope is that through this music we can find moments of peace and healing, and be reminded that even in the midst of difficulty, there is always space for hope and the simple joy of being together.

This concert also marks a special milestone for Musae, as we’re thrilled to present the world premiere of “Where Memories Grow” by the extraordinary composer Marie-Claire Saindon. Commissioned to honor Musae’s 20th anniversary, this piece was written especially for our ensemble, and we’ve loved collaborating with Marie-Claire, who has written a beautiful piece which resonates with Musae’s ethos and values. We’re deeply grateful to all of you—our cherished audience and donors—for making this possible. Your support has brought beautiful new music into the world that celebrates beauty, intimacy, and peace.

In times of adversity, music can be a powerful way to reconnect with our inner strength. Wherever you find your heart this holiday season, my hope is that this concert helps connect you to your loved ones, offers you comfort, and reminds you that joy is still worth seeking, even and especially amid challenges. May this music sustain you with peace, love, comfort, and joy for the season and beyond. Thank you for being part of this moment with us.

With love,

Elizabeth Kimble Artistic Director, Musae

TIDINGS OF COMFORT AND JOY

Elizabeth Kimble,
Artistic Director

I. ​ In Sweet Joy

IN DULCI JUBILO
Traditional German Carol, arr. John Rutter (b. 1945), translated from German by Robert Lucas Pearsall (1795-1856)

II. ​ The Bleak Midwinter

IN THE BLEAK MIDWINTER
WORLD PREMIERE, Gustav Holst (1874-1934), arr. Elizabeth Kimble (b. 1986), text by Christina Rossetti (1830-1894)

IN THE BLEAK MIDWINTER
from “A Boy Is Born", Benjamin Britten (1913-1976), text by Christina Rossetti and anonymous (“Corpus Christi Carol”)

III.  ​​Seeking Comfort

THERE WILL BE REST
Frank Ticheli (b. 1958), text by Sara Teasdale (1884-1933)

IV. ​​ Lullabies

LULLAY, MY LIKING
Gerda Blok-Wilson (b. 1955), 15th-Century Traditional English text by anonymous

SEAL LULLABY
Eric Whitacre (b. 1970), text by Rudyard Kipling (1865-1936)

V. ​​ Awe

WHERE MEMORIES GROW
WORLD PREMIERE, Music and Text by Marie-Claire Saindon (living composer)

HEAVEN FULL OF STARS
Eric William Barnum (b. 1979), text by Sara Teasdale

VI. ​​ Return To Joy

MY SPIRIT SANG ALL DAY
Gerald Finzi (1901-1956), arr. Elizabeth Kimble, text by Robert Bridges (1844-1930)

GOD REST YOU MERRY, GENTLEMEN
Traditional English Carol, arr. David Willcocks (1919-2015)

Program Notes

I. 

The beloved carol In Dulci Jubilo has a rich history dating back to the Middle Ages. Originally written in a blend of medieval German and Latin by the German mystic Heinrich Seuse, the German text was later translated into English by the composer Robert Lucas de Pearsall, who retained the carol’s original macaronic structure. This adaptation made the joyful hymn accessible to English-speaking audiences while preserving its medieval charm. John Rutter’s arrangement breathes new life into the traditional carol through his signature harmonizations and dynamic choral textures, enhancing its jubilant character and inviting listeners to partake in the timeless celebration of Christmas joy.

II.

In the Bleak Midwinter is a beloved Christmas carol with lyrics by Christina Rossetti, notable for having two distinct melodies—one by Gustav Holst and another by Harold Darke. Rossetti’s 1872 poem, “A Christmas Carol,” vividly portrays the humble setting of Christ’s birth, highlighting the quiet, solemn beauty of the Nativity amid the cold of winter. In the arrangement you’ll hear today by Musae’s Artistic Director, Elizabeth Kimble, the familiar melody by Gustav Holst is accompanied by increasingly intricate polychordal harmonies, evoking the icy beauty of the season and the soaring “angels and archangels” surrounding the manger.

Benjamin Britten’s cantata “A Boy Was Born” is a striking choral work that integrates several traditional Christmas carols, seamlessly woven with Britten’s distinctive harmonies and textures. One of the highlights is the fifth movement, In the Bleak Midwinter, where Britten’s arrangement offers a fresh perspective on the beloved carol. Using Christina Rossetti’s text, Britten employs tone painting to evoke a mysterious scene of swirling snow, creating an atmospheric texture that supports a solo line singing the Corpus Christi Carol. This medieval poem allegorizes the death of Jesus through the image of a wounded knight, interweaving Arthurian symbolism with Christian themes.

III. 

Frank Ticheli’s choral setting of Sara Teasdale’s poem There Will Be Rest is a poignant meditation on peace and solace, rich with lyricism and harmonic warmth. Teasdale’s text, written in 1937, reflects her lifelong search for serenity amid the struggles of her mental health and a turbulent personal life. Despite critical acclaim and a Pulitzer Prize, Teasdale’s journey was often shadowed by solitude and inner turmoil. She wrote this poem near the end of her life, expressing a profound longing for rest and transcendence, themes that resonate deeply with Ticheli’s musical interpretation.

The structure of Ticheli’s composition mirrors the poem’s introspective nature, unfolding in lush, extended phrases that emphasize the text’s reflective mood. Ticheli opens with gentle, shifting harmonies that convey the poem’s sense of quiet resignation. As the piece progresses, the harmonies grow richer, exploring subtle dissonances and suspensions that underscore the text’s somber beauty and its yearning for release. Ticheli’s use of dynamic contrast and text painting further draws out the imagery of stars, silence, and rest, offering the choir moments of both intensity and calm. The work culminates in a soft, reverent conclusion, offering a sense of closure and stillness.

IV.

Gerda Blok-Wilson’s Lullay, My Liking beautifully brings to life the intimate warmth and tender reverence of a 15th-century English carol. The text, drawn from an anonymous Middle English lyric, expresses a mother’s gentle lullaby to the Christ child, blending personal devotion with mystical awe. The refrain, "Lullay, my liking, my dear son, my sweeting," reflects a tender, almost lullaby-like quality, while the verses celebrate the child’s divine nature with reverent simplicity.

Blok-Wilson’s setting honors the traditional text by crafting a lush, reflective atmosphere. Her use of gentle, lilting rhythms and open, modal harmonies evokes the simplicity and purity of early English carols, while her contemporary harmonic language adds warmth and depth. The piece begins softly, like a mother’s quiet lullaby, building subtly through layered voices to moments of richer harmonic texture, inviting the listener into an atmosphere of peace and quiet wonder. Throughout, Blok-Wilson’s attention to textural nuance and phrasing, highlight the intimacy of the text, drawing out both its sweetness and its devotional spirit.

Eric Whitacre’s The Seal Lullaby is a tender, hauntingly beautiful choral work based on a poem by Rudyard Kipling. Originally composed for an animated film adaptation of Kipling’s “The Jungle Book” that never came to fruition, Whitacre’s piece found life instead as a beloved concert work. The text, from Kipling’s “The White Seal,” is a lullaby sung by a mother seal to her pup, a gentle, protective song that conjures images of the ocean’s ebb and flow, conveying both comfort and mystery. The piece beautifully expresses the universal theme of love and protection, offering listeners a moment of quiet reflection and comfort, as timeless as Kipling’s words and as tender as a lullaby itself.

Whitacre’s music enhances the lullaby’s soothing, oceanic quality through his characteristic lush harmonies and fluid, undulating rhythms. The piece opens with soft, undulating piano chords that suggest the gentle motion of waves, creating a soundscape of warmth and peace. As the choir enters, the voices weave together in seamless flowing lines, that mirror the mother seal’s embrace and her wish to shelter her young one from the dangers of the sea. Whitacre uses rich dynamic contrasts and subtle shifts in harmony to convey both the love and underlying vulnerability in Kipling’s text. The piece builds to a climactic moment, only to return to a soft, delicate close, like a gentle tide receding. 

V. 

Musae is honored to present the world premiere of Where Memories Grow by the Canadian composer Marie-Claire Saindon, commissioned to celebrate Musae’s 20th anniversary season. In writing this piece, Saindon sought to capture the subtle power of an intimate childhood memory—a seemingly simple but profoundly resonant experience shared with her brother on a winter’s night. 

She writes, “Some seemingly mundane moments stay with us forever. A touch, a smile, a silent pause with a loved one. One winter night, my brother and I made our way to our wooded backyard and lay on our backs in the snow to listen to the wind whistle through the frosty trees for a solid five minutes. No words were exchanged before, during, or after. This small moment in time has deeply marked me. Over time, it highlighted to me the intimacy and nostalgia that can be only found within memories shared between two young humans discovering the existence of the world’s mysteries surrounding them.”

Saindon’s music reflects the wonder and serenity of that memory, evoking the gentle sway of wind in the trees and the quiet presence shared by two people absorbed in the natural world. Through layers of harmony and melodic interplay, she captures the stillness and mystery of this formative moment. Her work invites listeners into a similar state of reflection, where the profound can emerge from the simple and the beauty of memory can linger like a winter’s whisper.

In Heaven Full of Stars, composer Eric William Barnum draws on Sara Teasdale’s evocative poetry to create a shimmering choral work that captures the beauty and mystery of the night sky. Teasdale’s text explores themes of awe, wonder, and humility—qualities that resonate with Barnum’s music, which interweaves lush harmonies and subtle dissonances to mirror the celestial scene she describes.

Teasdale, known for her lyrical and emotionally direct poetry, often wrote about nature and spirituality. The text for this piece is excerpted from her poem "Stars," included in the collection Flame and Shadow, where she contemplates the vastness of the universe and her place within it—a theme that speaks to the fragility and beauty of human existence. Barnum’s setting deepens this meditative quality, employing varied textures and musical layers that open into an endless sky filled with stars, oscillating between serenity and power.

VI. 

My Spirit Sang All Day, composed by Gerald Finzi in 1937, is a radiant choral piece that reflects the British composer’s deep affinity for setting English poetry to music. Known for his sensitive, lyrical style, Finzi selected a poem by Robert Bridges to create a vivid musical landscape that captures the poet’s exaltation and joy. The work was written during Finzi's early courtship of Joyce Black, whom he lovingly called "Joy" and who would eventually become his wife—a fitting inspiration for this celebration of happiness and devotion. 

Bridges' text is simple yet expressive, using direct language to convey the speaker's elation and emotional freedom. Finzi underscores this joyful theme through lively rhythms, buoyant melodies, and dynamic contrasts, capturing the delight and sense of liberation that permeate the poem. Although brief, the piece resonates with a powerful, almost transcendental joy, lifting both singers and listeners into a moment of pure musical bliss. Originally composed for mixed choir, tonight’s performance will feature a unique arrangement for treble voices, offering a fresh interpretation of this beloved classic.

The beloved English carol God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen has been a staple of the Christmas season for centuries, with origins tracing back to the 17th century. Its comforting message and cheerful, memorable tune have cemented it as one of the most iconic carols in the English-speaking world. 

This arrangement by the distinguished British composer, conductor, and arranger David Willcocks brings new life to the traditional melody through his signature harmonies and varied choral textures. Willcocks, known for his work with the Choir of King’s College, Cambridge, elevated many classic carols with his arrangements, adding sophistication and depth that have made them both timeless and uniquely moving. In this version of God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen, Willcocks maintains the carol’s inherent joy while enhancing it with nuanced harmonies and lively dynamics that bring warmth and richness to the familiar tune. His use of contrasting choral textures and harmonies, and his careful attention to phrasing and articulation, create a vibrant and celebratory sound. Willcocks’ arrangement transforms the carol from a simple, familiar tune into a piece of choral artistry, beloved by choirs and audiences alike for its sense of festive cheer and timeless beauty.

Texts & Translations

  • In dulci jubilo (In sweet joy)

    Let us our homage shew;

    Our heart’s joy reclineth

    In praesepio (In a manger)

    And like a bright star shineth

    Matris in gremio. (in the mother’s lap.)

    Alpha es et O. (You are the Alpha and Omega.)


    O Jesu parvule! (O tiny Jesus!)

    I yearn for the alway!

    Hear me, I beseech thee, 

    O Puer optime! (O best boy!)

    My prayer let it reach thee,

    O Princeps gloriae! (O Prince of glory!)

    Trahe me post te! (Draw me unto thee!)


    O Patris caritas, (O father’s love,)

    O Nati lenitas! (O newborn's mildness!)

    Deeply were we stainèd 

    Per nostra crimina; (By our crimes;)

    But thou has for us gainèd 

    Coelorum gaudia. (The joys of heaven.)

    O that we were there!


    Ubi sunt gaudia, (Where there are joys,)

    Where, if they be not there?

    There are angels singing 

    Nova cantica, (A new song,)

    There the bells are ringing

    In Regis curia: (In the King’s court:)

    O that we were there!

  • In the bleak midwinter, frosty wind made moan,

    Earth stood hard as iron, water like a stone;

    Snow had fallen, snow on snow, snow on snow,

    In the bleak midwinter, long ago.


    Our God, Heaven cannot hold Him, nor earth sustain;

    Heaven and earth shall flee away when He comes to reign.

    In the bleak midwinter a stable place sufficed

    The Lord God Almighty, Jesus Christ.


    Angels and archangels may have gathered there,

    Cherubim and seraphim thronged the air;

    But His mother only, in her maiden bliss,

    Worshipped the belovèd with a kiss.


    What can I give Him, poor as I am?

    If I were a shepherd, I would bring a lamb;

    If I were a Wise Man, I would do my part;

    Yet what I can I give Him: give my heart.


    Corpus Christi Carol 

    He bare him up, he bare him down,

    He bare him into an orchard brown.


    Lully, lullay, Lully, lullay, 

    The falcon hath borne my make away


    In that orchard there was a hall,

    That was hangëd with purple and pall.

    And in that hall there was a bed, 

    It was hangëd with gold so red.


    Lully, lullay…


    In that bed there lieth a knight, 

    His woundës bleeding, day and night.

    By that bedside kneeleth a may, 

    And she weepeth both night and day.


    Lully, lullay…


    And by that bedside there standeth a stone,

    Corpus Christi written there on.

  • There will be rest, and sure stars shining

    Over the roof-tops crowned with snow,

    A reign of rest, serene forgetting,

    The music of stillness holy and low.


    I will make this world of my devising,

    Out of a dream in my lonely mind,

    I shall find the crystal of peace, —above me

    Stars I shall find.

  • Lullay, my Liking,

    My dear Son, my Sweeting;

    Lullay my dear Heart, 

    Mine own dear Darling.


    I saw a fair maiden 

    sitten and sing:

    She lulled a little Child, 

    a sweet é Lording.


    Lullay…


    Angels bright, they sang that night 

    and saiden to that Child,

    “Blessed be Thou and 

    Blessed be she that is so meek and mild.”


    Lullay…


    Pray we now to that Child, 

    And to his mother dear,

    God grant them all His blessing 

    that now maken cheer.


    Lullay…

  • Oh! hush thee, my baby, the night is behind us,

    And black are the waters that sparkled so green.

    The moon, o’er the combers, looks downward to find us

    At rest in the hollows that rustle between.


    Where billow meets billow, then soft be thy pillow;

    Ah, weary wee flipperling, curl at thy ease!

    The storm shall not wake thee, nor shark overtake thee, 

    Asleep in the arms of the slow-swinging seas.

  • And there, 

    Fresh snow for a pillow, 

    Under a starry quilt, 

    We lie.


    And there, 

    Frosted breaths swirling,

    Eyes turned heavenward,

    We float.


    And there, 

    Though snow melts at dawn

    And dreams mist away in time —

    There we’ll always be,

    Heeding sacred whispers

    Through frozen boughs,

    Where the world sighs

    And memories grow.

  • Alone in the night

    On a dark hill

    With pines around me

    Spicy and still, 


    And heaven full of stars

    Over my head

    White and topaz

    And misty red;


    Myriads with beating

    Hearts of fire

    That aeons

    Cannot vex or tire;


    Up the dome of heaven

    Like a great hill, 

    I watch them marching

    Stately and still,


    And I know that I

    Am honored to be

    Witness

    Of so much majesty.

  • My spirit sang all day

    O my joy.

    Nothing my tongue could say,

    Only my joy!


    My heart an echo caught

    O my joy

    And spake,

    Tell me thy thought,

    Hide not thy joy.


    My eyes ‘gan peer around,

    O my joy,

    What beauty hast thou found?

    Shew us thy joy.


    My jealous ears grew whist;

    O my joy

    Music from heaven is't,

    Sent for our joy?


    She also came and heard;

    O my joy,

    What, said she, is this word?

    What is thy joy?


    And I replied,

    O see,

    O my joy,

    'Tis thee, I cried,

    'Tis thee:

    Thou art my joy.

  • God rest you merry, gentlemen,

    Let nothing you dismay, 

    Remember Christ our Saviour

    Was born on Christmas day, 

    To save us all from Satan’s power

    When we were gone astray:


    O tidings of comfort and joy, comfort and joy,

    O tidings of comfort and joy.


    From God our heav’nly Father

    A blessed angel came,

    And unto certain shepherds

    Brought tidings of the same,

    How that in Bethlehem was born

    The Son of God by name: 


    O tidings…


    The shepherds at those tidings

    Rejoicèd much in mind, 

    And left their flocks afeeding, 

    In tempest, storm and wind, 

    And went to Bethlehem straightway

    This blessed babe to find:


    O tidings…


    But when to Bethlehem they came

    Where at this infant lay, 

    They found him in a manger, 

    Where oxen feed on hay;

    His mother Mary kneeling, 

    Unto the Lord did pray:


    O tidings…


    Now to the Lord sing praises, 

    All you within this place,

    And with true love and brotherhood

    Each other now embrace; 

    This holy tide of Christmas

    All others doth deface:


    O tidings…

Artist Bios

Elizabeth Kimble (she/they) is a conductor, composer, soprano, and psychotherapist whose music explores the sacred and psychological dimensions of human experience. Currently the Artistic Director of Musae, Elizabeth has also served as the Music Director of Tactus SF and Assistant Conductor of the International Orange Chorale of San Francisco.  A versatile vocalist, Elizabeth has performed as both a soloist and ensemble member with many distinguished choral groups, including the San Francisco Symphony Chorus, Cappella SF, Gaude, Clerestory, Volti, and the California Bach Society. Their compositions have been performed by the Swedish Radio Choir, Cappella SF, and SF Sound, and some of their liturgical music is published by Selah. She holds a MM in Music Composition from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, dual BMs in Music Composition and Vocal Performance from Baldwin-Wallace College Conservatory of Music, and an MA in Counseling Psychology with an emphasis in Depth Psychology from Pacifica Graduate Institute. In addition to their musical endeavors, Elizabeth practices as an Associate Marriage and Family Therapist. Learn more at elizabethkimblemusic.com.

Marie-Claire Saindon is a Franco-Ontarian composer based in Montréal. She is composer-in-residence for Chor Leoni (2024-2027) and for Chœur Adleisia, runs creative choral/vocal workshops, and enjoys teaching Irish fiddle. She currently writes choral, chamber, and orchestral commissions and creates film and multimedia scores. Her other collaborative experiences span from accompanying dancers to fiddling in a team of folk musicians on a historical steam train. Recipient of multiple composition prizes (such as the SOCAN Young Composers' National Awards in the vocal category, 2013, and the Ruth Watson Henderson Choral Composition Competition, 2018), her choral works are published with Boosey & Hawkes, Cypress Choral Music, Hal Leonard Choral, Earthsongs Choral Music, and Alliance Music Publications. Her film scores can be found on documentaries hosted on CBC Gem and Radio-Canada. Marie-Claire holds a BMus: Composition from the Schulich School of Music (McGill, 2007) and an MMus: Composition - Film and Multimedia music from Université de Montréal (2010). Learn more at marieclairesaindon.com.

Musae is a treble vocal ensemble based in San Francisco. The group takes its name from the original "ladies of song," the classic nine Muses of Greek mythology. Since its founding in 2004, Musae has performed diverse and accessible music throughout the Bay Area, and continues to stretch the boundaries of traditional repertoire for treble voices. Musae functions as a musical collective, in which each singer identifies as a leader and soloist contributing actively to the artistic process. The group's singers are trained in the choral tradition, but not bound by it. Each singer may sing a range of voice parts based on the aesthetic demands of the music, and the group performs largely without a conductor.

Musae Board of Directors

Colleen O’Hara
​Elizabeth Stumpf
Erika Anderson
Kirstin Cummings
​​Laney McClain Armstrong
Lynne Carmichael
Matthew Levine
Michela Macfarlane

Special Thanks

Anjali Jameson
Baldvin Smarason
Blake Williams
Brent Williams
Jeffrey Parola
Kate Sommer
Katie Innes
Quentin Williams
Sydney Weaver

Thank you to our patrons
for their charitable contributions given between
November 15, 2023 and November 15, 2024

MAJOR GODS ($1000 AND ABOVE)

Colleen O’Hara and Brendan Downs
Dave McKie and Mary Euretig
Deborah and Seán O'Hara
Elizabeth Stumpf
Erika Anderson and Dan Sommer
Karin and Greg McClune
Lynne Carmichael
Matthew and Monica Levine
Michael Gordon, in memory of Martha Hoover
Nancy Montgomery
Valerie Moy

MINOR GODS ($500 AND ABOVE)

Amy Strauss and Kevin Dugan
Anjali and David
Bev and Fred Lynk
Cynthia and Dave Blumgart
David and Amy Kalish
Elizabeth Kimble
Kate Sommer
Kathy and Gary Holland
Katie Innes
Kenneth Moy
Michela Macfarlane
Sabrina Adler
Sydney Weaver

MUSES ($250 AND ABOVE)

Abigail Ramsden and Kevin Frank
Allison Lynk
Barrie McClune
Becca Schonberg
Cecily Burrill
Chesley Herbert
Danielle Schickele
Ellisha Blechynden and Alex Purtill
Kim McClain
Kirstin Cummings
Kit Hodge
Lauren Schwartz
Leslie Innes
Marie Herbert
Mollie Brown and Warren Browner
Patricia Kristof Moy
Teresa Weaver

SIRENS ($100 AND ABOVE)

Angela Murray
Annette Sarraille
Bertha McKinley
Dave Strauss
Ellen, Peter, and Jiah Barnett
Evelyn and John Cobley
Gary Wynbrandt
Gloria Sparrow
Haley and Gabe Cohn
Linda Nussbaum and Larry Ross
Madison Tyler
Paul and Jane Emmert Stewart
Peter Bartelme
Rachel Herbert
Ray-Whay Chiu Yen, in honor of Valerie Moy
Rebecca and William Stewart
Sally and Steve Schroeder
Sherrie Hansen
Simon Bare
Teresa and Dan Newmark
The Caldwells
William and Susan Lukens

POETS (UP TO $100)

Allen Blatter
Andrei Duca
Andrew Martella
Anonymous
Anonymous, in honor of Katie Innes
Ben Ross
Borja Moreno Bosch
Ceil Scandone
Cris Moy
Dan G. Moy
Daniel P. Moy
Evelin and Paul Brinich
Iniyai Thiruvalluvan
James Martling and Kristine Kelley
Jessica Dillon
Judy Hodkiewicz
Kate Sylvester
Kelly Close
Kristin Krueger
Linda Gallaher-Brown
M. Engle
Macy Family
Marq Short
Miguelito
Mike Dottin
Mike Winston
Minh Nguyen
Robin Flecha
Sharon Silva
Susie Breuer
Suzanne Ensley